November Battle of the Exclusives: Uncharted vs. Mass Effect vs. Super Mario Galaxy

[Toxic]

I know the games are two completely different genres. But the fact still remains that these titles represent the heavy hitter exclusives for their respective consoles during this holiday season. Which do you believe will be the better game, have the best graphics, and sell the most?

[Scott]

ME will sell more. Both games look good graphically. ME looks cleaner and Uncharted looks more like the real world we live in. I say Uncharted graphically because it has that real world, dirty, gritty look that I like whereas a game set in the future is prone to have a more cleaner look but I think most other people would say ME.

Umm better game? What is that dependant on? If you are talking review scores then no doubt ME will get better scores as it will have online play, longer lenght and is a futuristic alien shooting game that the media loves. If I had both systems I'd get both but if I had to choose I'd only pick Uncharted because it has platforming elements and just seems like old school fun.

[Toxic]

Umm better game? What is that dependant on?

Your enjoyment of the game is really the only barometer by which to judge the quality of the product. Seeing as though none of us have played either game in question, I guess we'd have to say based on what you know of both which appeals to you the most. And you answered that, frankly Bioware RPG, IMHO, equals instant classic

[DeadCell]

Mass Effect will sell more.

I want Uncharted, though.

Super Mario Galaxy will be the one I purchase.

[Ghost]

Mario Galaxy is going to outsell both of those games combined.

[Metallica1983]

Mario Galaxy is going to outsell both of those games combined.

well everyone knows that

[jakncoke]

Well to go by anything SMG is the best rated but doesn't look like the awesomeness of Uncharted and Mass Effect, I will be getting Uncharted and Mass Effect and pass on SMG( not getting a wii if I was SMG would be a first purchase) In terms of sales SMG will win for November NPD ( they sold 500k there first week) then Mass Effect(my prediction about 350k for nov npd) and Uncharted will finish last amongst the 3 and probably won't even reach top 10 for the month sadly. For LTD SMG imo will lead the overall with about 3.5 million ltd and Mass Effect imo will stop at 2 million ltd, Uncharted although awesome might not even reach 1 million sold sadly.

So after all that Uncharted and Mass Effect get my win