Adobe Photoshop CS5... Should I?

[Aniki]

So, I only use Photoshop for making sigs or to render images, but there is one feature on Adobe Photoshop CS5 that really calls my attention... 3D Text! I know that the new version has a lot of another features, but that's exactly what scares me!
I mean, in the last days my I've filled up my computer with some files that are big and useless, and now I gotta clean all this mess to make it better. But there's a problem tho: I don't want to keep both Photoshops, but CS5 is new and more confusing (to me) but the 3D text is a great improvement for my sigs...

So: my computer is half-full, I have no experience in Photoshop CS5 (kinda scared) but 3D Text would be a great improvement... Should I get it?

[Samus-Fan]

If you have the money, I would.
My experience is though, I still use Photoshop CS2.

I have CS3 and CS4 on my computer, but I don't like them. At all. and I imagine I won't like CS5 either. Its personal view, I see what effects I actually need and which program has them the easiest, which is CS2. Its all up to you though.
If you have the money or are being offered the program, sure. But if you're buying it, maybe put a lot of thought into if that 3D font is really worth it.

[LiNuX]

As samus said, if you have the money for it, go for it. I still use CS2 just like him, never had any interest in upgrading, I just needed photoshop for web stuff so I just got a version.

[Knibbler]

3D text is easy to create. So I wouldn't waste the money with your previous version.
I found that I really liked the UI of CS4 and CS5 did t really appeal to me much, hence why I use CS4.

[jango]

If it helps, I've often found with design or programming packages to ALWAYS try the trial version first. Like th others said above sometimes updated version might do minor/additional things, but often a dramatic update tends to remove some of the cool stuff of previous versions too. At least if you check out the trial version you might find if you dig it or not ..

As for my thoughts on CS4/5 .. well .. it's not relevant. Bit like saying I prefer these shoes to the ones you might like .. as pointless as a pencil in a blender.

[Diligence109]

(wisdom wisdom wisdom...) ALWAYS try the trial version first. (...wisdom eloquence wisdom...)

(...humility wisdom eloquence wisdom witty humor wisdom.)
(paraphrased for your convenience)

Trying the trial version for yourself will help you answer the question if it really has anything you really need and if you can work well with the new program. jango's the man, yo!

I, personally, use CS5. But I suck at graphics, so why would you listen to me?

[LemonRising]

I'm currently using CS3 (apparently the bastard child version of photoshop lmfao)

As Knibbler said, there are other ways to get 3D text, and if hard drive space is an issue, stick to what you know. Try to find tutorials that show you how to make 3D text, and experiment from there.

If you want to try and brave it out, get the trial, try and find your way around the new version (I remember being scared of trying Photoshop for the first time, so it's kind of like that except not as big a leap). From what I'm hearing there are a lot of awesome new features in CS5, and I might be making the jump sometime <: Maybe. lol


tl;dr either try making 3D text with tutorials in the version of Photoshop you have, or try the trial of CS5 and see how that goes.
I would say trial is plan A
tutorial 3D text plan B
: D

[Dess]

CS5, and I'm just learning how to do GFX. It really isn't that confusing. I haven't played with the 3D Text stuff yet, but I want to....


But yeah... like Jango said... just try the trial first. =P

BTW. Right now they have it on sale for $299. Just sayin.

[Ilyich Valken]

The 3D tools aren't really that great, and CS5 isn't that much of a step up from CS4, to be honest.

[Aniki]

Hm... I see. I did find a way of my own to make 3D text in Photoshop CS4, but it's kinda cheap... Very cool tho, since it doesn't requires that much work to make it ^^ Maybe I'll stick with CS4, but try the CS5 trial and see how it "works"...
Thanks for the opinions and suggestions guys!

[LemonRising]

Sounds like a plan, goodluck!


you'll have to show us a sig soon with some cool 3d text ;p

[Aniki]

Sounds like a plan, goodluck!


you'll have to show us a sig soon with some cool 3d text ;p

Eheh I never tried to, and my school is about to start, so if I made one it would be very cheap xD

BTW, I can't download Photoshop CS5 Trial for some reason... I go to the official website, I sign in first (they ask you to be4 download) and it just keeps loading... Boring D:>

[LemonRising]

Hm that's weird D:

and aright lol, Hopefully we get to see one eventually! : D

[Aniki]

Ok... I go to the adobe website, log in, go to Photoshop CS5 trial page and click 'Download Now' and then nothing happens, like it is just a normal button with no effect >_> Tried the same with Photoshop CS5 Extended...
Tried to look for the trial version on megaupload or rapidshare, but nothing ='(

[LemonRising]

Do you have a different browser to try it in?

Sometimes that'll do it

[Aniki]

Eheh I should have tried that already :P Tried it with Google Chrome and it's downloading! Now I'll play some PS3 and when I come back I'll start playing with the trial ^_^ Thanks for the advice xD

[LemonRising]

No problem, good to hear that it's working! : D

[Aniki]

Working, it's a cool version, pretty laggy since its a trial version or because I have both PS's, but I'm thinking on getting it. My friend told me if I have all those doubts and dunno if I should buy it, to get it from piratebay, but that's just wrong >_>"
So now I'm stuck again :P I like it, but I'm not very sure...

[LemonRising]

You should find out why its lagging.
It might be that your computer can't handle it. If that's the case then it might not be a good idea to get it lol



and yes... that's... wrong... ...

innocent whistle

[LiNuX]

look at how much memory is being used when the program runs, also look at cpu usage, either could be the cause of the lag. I doubt it's lagging because it's a trial version.

[LemonRising]

Yeah... what the smart computer guy said : D

[Aniki]

I've solven the lag problem. Turns out that some days ago, while cleaning my room, I found a bunch of old but working games, which I used to play when very little :P I just went in a rage and installed everything and what eva was on it xD But now it's ok, no problem!

[LemonRising]

lmfao yeah that can do it sometimes.

glad its working properly now! : D

[Aniki]

I guess I'll just stick with Photoshop CS4. CS5 is kinda ugly (eheh) and confusing, and it isn't that 'better' then CS4, at least for sig making. I mean, there are lots of new features and options, but nothing too better for sig making... :D