PDA

View Full Version : Rate Me My Past Few Works



LiNuX
07-13-2008, 12:50 PM
I haven't made a lot of sigs lately but below are the ones I've made and some opinions and ratings would be nice. My batman sig was the longest sig (in time it took to finish) because of the batman logo render (did it myself) but the overall sig took about 15 mins

The other two took from 5-10 mins each.

http://www.gamers-forum.com/imagehosting/1481b962c3df93.png

This one took me less than 5 mins because I made it to fill a spot in the SOTW lol. Also my first sig in months - batman was my last one in april i think.

http://www.gamers-forum.com/imagehosting/1486e555085efd.png

just made this one, i messed up a bit on the text but didn't feel like fixing it, another space filler.

http://www.gamers-forum.com/imagehosting/1487a3f3e9f55b.png

KittyCat72
07-13-2008, 12:56 PM
The Batman one is the best... the others look too easy. But they're still good. I'd rate them
7.7/10
5.8/10
6/10

Not sure though...

LiNuX
07-13-2008, 01:15 PM
The Batman one is the best... the others looks too easy. But they're still good. I'd rate them
7.7/10
5.8/10
6/10

Not sure though...

lol thanks - they are all easy and takes a few mins, i haven't learned any new tricks in the past 2 years I've been in PS mainly cuz i had over a year break in between and I know my artistic skills suck so i never bothered :D

thanks for ratings!

Jaykub
07-13-2008, 01:15 PM
1. 9/10

2. 8/10

3. 6.9/10

LiNuX
07-13-2008, 01:23 PM
1. 9/10

2. 8/10

3. 6.9/10

geez, thanks...helps a lot with just numbers, was expecting some words in the posts as well

Trunks
07-13-2008, 01:30 PM
Well when I rate signatures for SOTW and stuff I go by how well everything blends. Some people go by whos in the sig, which I think is dumb and missing the point. Some people also go with how many visual effects are in it, which is alright I guess.

I give your bat man sig, a 8/0. All the colors go well togoether. You stuck with red and blue which is the bat man theme ( for the bat man atleast. ) For your

bender one, I feel like theres to much empty space. Everything goes togother well, but there should be somthing else in it. 7/10

Your Pokemon one lacks the same thing. Theres a big empty space in the middle of it. Also, I don't understand the glow effect on the right side of the screen. I think that it should be near the pokemon. The pokemon is made of fire and it should have somthing showing that. 5/10

There pretty good for the amount of time you spent on them.

LiNuX
07-13-2008, 02:00 PM
Well when I rate signatures for SOTW and stuff I go by how well everything blends. Some people go by whos in the sig, which I think is dumb and missing the point. Some people also go with how many visual effects are in it, which is alright I guess.

I give your bat man sig, a 8/0. All the colors go well togoether. You stuck with red and blue which is the bat man theme ( for the bat man atleast. ) For your

bender one, I feel like theres to much empty space. Everything goes togother well, but there should be somthing else in it. 7/10

Your Pokemon one lacks the same thing. Theres a big empty space in the middle of it. Also, I don't understand the glow effect on the right side of the screen. I think that it should be near the pokemon. The pokemon is made of fire and it should have somthing showing that. 5/10

There pretty good for the amount of time you spent on them.

lol thank you, i like comments like this rather than just "9/10" :-P

bender one was a space filler again, well...not the sig space, the sotw space lol, i did simple brush strokes on the left to fill the emptiness, guess it wasn't great but oh well

and about the pokemon one - the background IS moltres, just super enlarged and liquified a bit. and the yellow stuff on the right side is moltres's flames. i tried, putting it right in front of him, doesn't look very good, well not to me at least lol

thanks for comments :) appreciate it

rukisuto
07-14-2008, 06:58 AM
You make sig background very well.
They're fluid and match the render pretty well :]

1. 7/10. It's the best on up there. All I would say is to put a bit more contrast in the background.

2. 5/10. Everything matches, but there is a lot of empty space.

3. 6/10. I love the fading background, it's smooth and matches moltres well. It's still pretty empty though.

LiNuX
07-14-2008, 10:38 AM
You make sig background very well.
They're fluid and match the render pretty well :]

1. 7/10. It's the best on up there. All I would say is to put a bit more contrast in the background.

2. 5/10. Everything matches, but there is a lot of empty space.

3. 6/10. I love the fading background, it's smooth and matches moltres well. It's still pretty empty though.

good backgrounds huh...lol, maybe renders aren't my thing then.

maybe i should make a bunch of backgrounds and distribute them :D

thanks for comments - i figured everyone would think the batman was the best one - it was my first sig of the year lol, and these were the only 3 i've made this whole year

rukisuto
07-14-2008, 03:21 PM
good backgrounds huh...lol, maybe renders aren't my thing then.

maybe i should make a bunch of backgrounds and distribute them :D

thanks for comments - i figured everyone would think the batman was the best one - it was my first sig of the year lol, and these were the only 3 i've made this whole year

I would say add some brushes or c4ds along with the render.
Spruce it up a bit :]

LiNuX
07-14-2008, 03:36 PM
I would say add some brushes or c4ds along with the render.
Spruce it up a bit :]

i used brushes for the top two - the moltres one is just a moltres in the background

and uh..you know those fighting scenes in pokemon where they have just weird looking backgrounds, abstract backgrounds and stuff - like with pikachu its all lightning or yellow or something lol, i tried to do that with moltres a bit while he's attacking - but i don't think i used enough wind lol...

meh...im not likely to change that, never usually touch my PSD after is save a work lol

rukisuto
07-14-2008, 03:40 PM
i used brushes for the top two - the moltres one is just a moltres in the background

and uh..you know those fighting scenes in pokemon where they have just weird looking backgrounds, abstract backgrounds and stuff - like with pikachu its all lightning or yellow or something lol, i tried to do that with moltres a bit while he's attacking - but i don't think i used enough wind lol...

meh...im not likely to change that, never usually touch my PSD after is save a work lol

I don't either unless I made it for someone and they ask me to change something.
I usually forget I saved it as a PSD.

LiNuX
07-14-2008, 03:42 PM
I don't either unless I made it for someone and they ask me to change something.
I usually forget I saved it as a PSD.

i just dont feel like opening it back up and looking at the layers and i'll be a bit confused lol, so i dont bother

i have dozens of PSDs in my external HDD, only saved them cuz they have a png, gif, or jpeg image with them :D

Kujo
07-14-2008, 05:16 PM
Batman was the better of the 3. 9/10 from me. the others split a 7/10.