Mortal Kombat Trilogy Or Soul Calaber 4?
I love both games and it is a major toss up between the two. I love Soul Calaber 4, Ivy is the bomb, I want her whip/sword so bad! But then again, Barrakka and Cindell from MK are awesome, and the finishing moves are always entertaining. Soul Calaber can't say the same.
I think that the graphics are a major deciding factor. Although, if a game is still just as good, even though it has terrible graphics then it has to be a great game. Obviously SC has the best graphics out of the two, and MK leaves much to be desired.
I also love Tekken, but I haven't been able to play for a very long time.
There are many fighting games that could have a little more to them, but on the other hand some of the moves are absolutely astonishing.