No BS: Bioshock or Halo 3?

I know there won't be a LOT of legitimate posts in this thread until EVERYBODY can get their hands on Halo 3. But being as fair and impartial as you can be.... GOTY: which one gets it and why?

There's still Call of Duty 4, Mass Effect and Assassin's Creed to consider, but since they're not out, it's a two-way battle.

I'm not voting yet. Because I haven't played either lol

But I want to know what you think?

well i cant vote either since i havent played either yet but if i had to say i'd vote for Halo 3 - i've played the earlier versions for pc and found them both awesome - mostly offline but it has some good stories with some great weapons. and the graphics are amazing, compete with that, i dont think bioshock graphics are as good, well not from what i've seen so far

i have played bioshock and really loved it although i did get bored at some points. I have not played halo 3 either so i cant really say that it is good but looking at the past games and the reviews im guessing it is awesome.

Bioshock had good reviews too but i think halo 3 will be better :)

Sorry for this one but obevious that Halo 3 is better. :P

is it really that obvious XD have you played either of them yet?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jasperking

have you played either of them yet?

---

I haven't played Bioshock. But I have played H3 and it's a lot like H2 but with better graphics

have you completed halo 3 and how long did it take to complete if you have? cause bioshock took me a long time..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jasperking

have you completed halo 3 and how long did it take to complete if you have? cause bioshock took me a long time..

---

I haven't finished it yet. I got to level 3 but I forgot to save it. So, I'm back at the end of level 1.
It took me about 3 hours to get to level 3 and there is about 9 levels

so 9 hours hopefully thats pretty good i guess. Bioshock took about 20 - 30 hours of nonstop play

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jasperking

so 9 hours hopefully thats pretty good i guess. Bioshock took about 20 - 30 hours of nonstop play

---

I have got to level 5 now in 4 hours (not including the game that wasn't saved). I'm going to try it on a higher difficulty once I finish it.