No BS: Bioshock or Halo 3?

I know there won't be a LOT of legitimate posts in this thread until EVERYBODY can get their hands on Halo 3. But being as fair and impartial as you can be.... GOTY: which one gets it and why?

There's still Call of Duty 4, Mass Effect and Assassin's Creed to consider, but since they're not out, it's a two-way battle.

I'm not voting yet. Because I haven't played either lol

But I want to know what you think?

well i cant vote either since i havent played either yet but if i had to say i'd vote for Halo 3 - i've played the earlier versions for pc and found them both awesome - mostly offline but it has some good stories with some great weapons. and the graphics are amazing, compete with that, i dont think bioshock graphics are as good, well not from what i've seen so far

i have played bioshock and really loved it although i did get bored at some points. I have not played halo 3 either so i cant really say that it is good but looking at the past games and the reviews im guessing it is awesome.

Bioshock had good reviews too but i think halo 3 will be better :)

Sorry for this one but obevious that Halo 3 is better. :P

is it really that obvious XD have you played either of them yet?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jasperking

have you played either of them yet?

---

I haven't played Bioshock. But I have played H3 and it's a lot like H2 but with better graphics

have you completed halo 3 and how long did it take to complete if you have? cause bioshock took me a long time..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jasperking

have you completed halo 3 and how long did it take to complete if you have? cause bioshock took me a long time..

---

I haven't finished it yet. I got to level 3 but I forgot to save it. So, I'm back at the end of level 1.
It took me about 3 hours to get to level 3 and there is about 9 levels

so 9 hours hopefully thats pretty good i guess. Bioshock took about 20 - 30 hours of nonstop play

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jasperking

so 9 hours hopefully thats pretty good i guess. Bioshock took about 20 - 30 hours of nonstop play

---

I have got to level 5 now in 4 hours (not including the game that wasn't saved). I'm going to try it on a higher difficulty once I finish it.

i usually go on the hardest mode of games as soon as i get them cause i love challenging games. but give us feedback on how long it takes u

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jasperking

i usually go on the hardest mode of games as soon as i get them cause i love challenging games. but give us feedback on how long it takes u

---

I'm not playing it anymore. I've gone back to Forza then I'm going to start The Darkness which sounds awesome too.

oh noes halo 3 isnt boring is it :( . Well i guess u just had enough of fps right

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jasperking

oh noes halo 3 isnt boring is it :( . Well i guess u just had enough of fps right

---

It's not that it's boring. I just want to finish Forza (Especially with PGR 4 on the way).
And I want to try The Darkness it looks good. And I hope I'm not done with FPS because The Darkness is one too lol

lol your right "The Darkness" looks like an awesome game but ive never heard of it b4. I might get it if it ever comes out for pc...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jasperking

lol your right "The Darkness" looks like an awesome game but ive never heard of it b4. I might get it if it ever comes out for pc...

---

It's a FPS where you control Demons and is made by 2k games It's also on the PS3.
Anyway back on topic. Once I get to play Bioshock I will vote

Halo 3 of course

i basicly think that halo 3 is the best online game ever lol. But bioshock has a better single player basicly.

personally i prefer halo 3 for depth and replayabilty.bioshock is a survival horror with rpg elements,hardly comparable to h3.bioshock has everything that critics go nuts over.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ghost

personally i prefer halo 3 for depth and replayabilty.bioshock is a survival horror with rpg elements,hardly comparable to h3.bioshock has everything that critics go nuts over.

---

Re playability?.... I can't replay it It isn't really that long and killing aliens gets boring after a while

Killing aliens is fun but you have to make creative ways to do it to keep it fun :)

my vote will still go for Halo 3..

i don't even know why you guys are discussing this, obviously its Halo3 ftw. :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Vamp

i don't even know why you guys are discussing this, obviously its Halo3 ftw. :D

---

Were comparing 2 of the best 360 games

Having played both on my friends 360 I would say Bioshock. It just seemed so different, you could organise a mini boss battle (big daddys) and with the plasmids...Its was near perfection if you ask me. But Halo 3 still is an awsome game and part of a legendary series.

i havent played either but for once i'll go against halo lol ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Razor

Having played both on my friends 360 I would say Bioshock. It just seemed so different, you could organise a mini boss battle (big daddys) and with the plasmids...Its was near perfection if you ask me. But Halo 3 still is an awsome game and part of a legendary series.

---

Not only did halo start of at legendary level in the entire game world, but mostly EVERYONE with an xbox or xbox360 knows about it. Not only that, but it's become so popular, you will hear national schools everywhere having discussions about it...Ahh i remember my time in line at EB games for halo 3, 200 people camping outside it... Good times...:D

I vote halo 3 since i haven't played bioshock. lol

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jasperking

i usually go on the hardest mode of games as soon as i get them cause i love challenging games. but give us feedback on how long it takes u

---

That's how my brother and I do it too. But I suck at Halo. Well my bro started on legendary and still does very well. And then when he wants more points for his tag he does it on the easier levels in a breeze. However since I suck at halo I couldn't start on legendary.

My m8 said that halo 3 is really boring unless you go on legendary.. and he sucks at games so that really shows on halo 3 :p

I've played both now, I've also played the first 2 Halos. And I have to say that Halo 3's single-player is a disappointment. It's too easy and as someones said somewhere all the Brutes do is side-step the AI is rubbish! and I am still looking for the enemies who apparently start at different places every time you restart. The graphics are good but not the best on the 360 and the story was good it had a better ending than 2.

But Bioshock on the other hand has good graphics difficult opponents (It doesnt have the best AI ever either though), you can carry more than 2 weapons and a good story but it is short and there is no single-player so its not going to last you very long.

So, in the end I think Bioshock is better it has better graphics and is more difficult.

Halo 3 is better it will last you longer. Well you will never want rid of it because of the multi-player

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jasperking

My m8 said that halo 3 is really boring unless you go on legendary.. and he sucks at games so that really shows on halo 3 :p

---

Halo is easy because the AI is so bad

Are we voting on Xbox i dont realy know. I played Bioshock and i played Halo 3 so i realy dont know... Bioshock i think he will be presedent the game of the year with crysis 2... So i vote fo Bioshock cus Halo 3 hase all 10/10 but it isnt pronounced a game of the year and bioshock hase so ...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kiba

Are we voting on Xbox i dont realy know. I played Bioshock and i played Halo 3 so i realy dont know... Bioshock i think he will be presedent the game of the year with crysis 2... So i vote fo Bioshock cus Halo 3 hase all 10/10 but it isnt pronounced a game of the year and bioshock hase so ...

---

Yeah there both 360 games but it doesn't matter which version you've played