Scarier? Doom 3 and F.E.A.R

[Home32]

I haven't posted here in forever.
Alright, so I just started playing Doom 3, and I've played some of F.E.A.R... The choice should be obvious but I'd like to hear other opinions on the matter. For me... Fear was practically a horror game, and then an action game, then they combined and I was like "I can't take this anymore." And bailed. Doom 3 seems like it's trying to hard, and only made me jump when a piece of metal fell off the wall... And it's boring as crap. (Freaking spiders...)
Opinions? Feedback? Waffles?